Electric vs Propane Smoker

The war of Electric vs Propane Smoker will initially come down to what they mean.

An electric smoker is cooking equipment that is used to smoke the food with the help of hot electric rods.

A propane smoker or a gas smoker is more or less the same kind of cooking device that makes use of propane instead of rods to smoke the food.


Is an electric or propane smoker better?

These are the smokers which have many features in common. They are both pocket-friendly and easy to use. However, to answer which type of smoker is best? this article will not down the pros and cons and leave it for the reader to decide. Here is Electric vs propane smoker.

Electric Smoker


i) The availability of a dial helps in adjusting the temperature. All you have to do is whirl it towards the low, medium, or hot settings.

ii) Once you have set the smoker, you can roam around freely with the advantage of even forgetting.

iii) Electric smokers are allowed even in apartments unlike other variety of smokers

iv) They are very safe to use as they possess no such combustible gases or material.

v) It can be easily converted into a cold smoker and are suitable for smoking subtle foods like fish


i) An electric smoker does not produce high heat, unlike propane smokers.

ii) To operate an electric smoker, you must have a power plug. This feature makes it impossible to go camping with.

iii) It is not easy to get the smoke rings using an electric smoker.

iv) Repairing the smoker can cost you many bucks. Along with that, because of their more hi-tech nature, they are complex to repair as well.

Here is Electric vs propane smoker.

Propane Smoker


i) You don’t need to have a power plug to operate them, hence they are travel-friendly.

ii) The repairs aren’t much of a headache as they are easy to get done.

iii) They don’t require electricity to function.

iv) They are more economical than electric smokers.

v) The outcomes of using propane smokers are similar to traditional Charcoal smokers, unlike electric smokers.


i) Propane smokers tend to become hot and therefore need a constant temperature vigil.

ii) These smokers are not designed with a full insulation mechanism. Hence on windy cold days, they might affect the cooking time.

iii) Some complexes do not allow the propane smoker user to operate it in there.

iv) These are low-tech devices and hence do not support other connectivity features like Bluetooth etc.

We have jotted down the pros and cons of both electric and propane smokers. It is not possible to give a general idea as to which smoker is better. It depends upon people who are planning to buy it. If the features they desire, match with electric smoker they are going to buy that and vice versa

Now, to bring the war, head to head we are going to compare them under different heads.

How do I choose a smoker?

Many Electric vs propane smoker reviews help in deciding how to choose a smoker. These reviews are helpful as they assist in understanding the requirements and whether a particular type of smoker can achieve it.

Simply put, if you wish to wager the world of delicate smoked food like fish or a dehydrated diet like jerky, an electric smoker is just a thing you are looking for.

However, if you are desiring a more conventional charcoal smoker flavor and aroma, a propane smoker is your diamond.

Nevertheless, if you are unsure about your yearnings, the following factors will help you conclude and reach your decision.

1. Cost

Generally, propane smokers are cheaper to buy. The gas models which are very cheap are easily affordable, however, they compromise the quality then.

Electric smokers are also inexpensive if one doesn’t wish for the latest features of Bluetooth connectivity.

The cost of acquiring might be low for propane smokers but the operating cost is comparatively high for electric smokers.

2. Use

Electric smokers are easy to use. All you have to do is set the temperature and leave it. However, unlike them, propane smokers need constant vigil as the temperature might fluctuate.

3. Taste

If you are someone who wishes to have a tarnished food with a taste similar to that of charcoal smokers, propane smokers are your best deal. Nevertheless, if you are on a delicate and dehydrated food tangent, opt for an electric smoker.

4. Reliability

Electric smokers are comparatively more reliable than propane smokers. They are well made, easy to use, and help in cooking the best food.

5. Bad weather conditions

Electric smokers are four-season friendly smokers. It can take up the rain, sun, wind, unlike propane smokers that aren’t well insulated to protect the cooking temperature from the external environment.

6. The final thought

It solely depends on the purpose you have in mind before buying a smoker.

Nevertheless, if you wish to have a general-purpose smoker with no particular feature in mind, opt for an electric one.

Here is Electric vs propane smoker.

Why are there no smoke rings in an electric smoker?

This is because oxygen is the major element required for the combustion to happen along with the right kind of fuel which will burn with it. Electric smokers do not make use of fuel but are designed with heating rods that work on electricity. Hence there is an unavailability of material to combust to produce smoke.

Electric vs Propane smoker taste

Taste is a subjective topic to discuss, but the consensus says that there happens to be a marked difference between the food outcomes.

Electric smokers generate milder flavors of the smoke department. They are not able to develop a smoky flavor because of the nature of their electric heating elements.

Propane smoker, on the other hand, produces more of a conventional smoky flavor. They won’t accomplish the flavor of charcoal smokers but they will be between the two: charcoal and electric. Now you know all about Electric vs propane smoker.

Are electric smokers worth it?

The following reasons will answer this question effectively.

1. Perfect for beginners

Electric smokers can be set at the desired temperature and time for you to smoke. It offers a set and forgets convenience which implies that you don’t need to engage in constant supervision while the food is in making all you need to do is set the temperature and time and forget about the food at all. It will force stop once it will reach the set time.

2. Price

Not only the initial price tag but also the long-term operating cost is affordable when it comes to electric smokers. However, nowadays with the latest features in action, its price has moved onto a little costly tangent. But you always have an option to eliminate the thought of buying a high-tech electric smoker if your pocket doesn’t allow it.

3. Manageable

All you need to do to operate electric smokers is to fill up the water tray, add some chips, plug in the unit, adjust the setting, allow it to reach the temperature, and then add the food.

Given the above reason, it is justifiable to say that an electric smoker is worth every ounce of their being and the money spent if you are not someone craving a smoky taste. It has a different taste and is typically considered well for delicate foods as well as dehydrated foods like jerks.

Here is the basic difference of Electric vs propane smoker.

Is smoking better than grilling?

The major distinction between smoking and grilling is time. Smoking is a lengthy process that includes cooking food evenly at constant temperature vigilance.

Grilling on the other hand is more attainable and is a quick process but smoking deepens the flavor which is impossible to imitate.

If you are someone who has unmatched love for flavor and aroma, smoking might be a better option. However, if you are living under a time constraint, well grilling can be your way to go. Hence, here is Electric vs propone smoker.


1. How long will a 20lb propane tank last on a smoker?

A discarding propane tank of nearly 14 or 16-ounce survives for about 1.5 to 2 hours.
A regular 20 lb propane tank continues for almost 18-20 hours on several grills.

2. What is the best smoker for a beginner?

For a beginner, an electric smoker is proven to be best as they have a set and forget feature which allows the user to set the temperature and time and then venture into the playful world without actually concerning about the food being spoiled. Apart from that, its worth is already mentioned above.

3. Do you soak wood chips for propane smokers?

Soaking the wood chips and chunks is not crucial because:
It requires 24 hours for the water to fully penetrate the wood
Soaked wood produces steam
Soaked wood lowers the smoker’s temperature.
Wood chips and chunks that have been soaked are compelled to get rid of any moisture content to produce smoke. The water on the wood will have to heat up to 212 F to get evaporated and produce smoke. Here is Electric vs propane smoker.

Kelly Anne

Kelly Anne

Hey there, I am Kelly Anne. Thank you for being here. Hope you like the website and it was helpful. I am a working mother of 2. I love to cook and feed people. My hobbies include cooking (obviously), reading, and rock climbing.

With so many machines and accessories in the market to help you cook it become quite overwhelming to choose from. I own a lot of these kitchen equipments and tried out the others. I want the best for my kitchen and I am helping you find the best for yours.

All Posts